The Signpost

File:Three giraffes 01.jpg
Byrdyak
cc-by-sa-4.0
100
50
600
Debriefing

Giraffer's RfA debriefing

Contribute   —  
Share this
By Giraffer

My request for adminship was closed as successful (221/0/1) on March 1, 2025. This is a debrief of my process to get there, and some takeaways from my experience. I hope you find it informative, or at the very least, interesting. I've broken it up into five sections: not wanting to run, deciding and preparing to run, the RfA itself, reflecting on the process, and thanking people.

Refusing

For roughly three years I had people asking me to run for adminship, and I refused. I didn't want to run for multiple reasons: I didn't think I was qualified, I didn't think I was active enough, I wasn't confident enough, and I didn't want to run during a trial period. Not all of these were true by the end, though—I was elected (partially) because I'm self-reflective, and holding multiple nomination offers whilst claiming you are unqualified doesn't quite embody that.

The biggest bottleneck among these factors was definitely my confidence. For a long time I felt that I was competent in the areas I wanted to do admin work in, but that I hadn't achieved the mastery I felt I needed to run for adminship.

To be clear, RfA's culture was not a reason for my procrastination. I wasn't very worried about the RfA climate. That is not a reflection on whether I thought I would pass or not, but my understanding of the system and how I thought it would treat me if things went south. I think I was probably an unusual candidate in that I opposed multiple (seven) candidates before running, some quite early on. I always tried to be honest but respectful in my opposition, and I think it helped me in my own run—I was able to draw on my votes and think critically about myself. I also thought that knowing how it feels to oppose someone would help me deal with opposition against myself, but I suppose that went untested.

Reconsidering

I reached a point in September 2024 where I was sick of waiting for administrator actions I felt that I could perform myself. My activity and my confidence had both improved, and I decided to start formally planning for an RfA. I briefly considered running in the admin elections, but I felt they would be too unpredictable and that my relatively low name recognition would benefit from more individual attention, not less.

In early December, I reached out to Kevin (L235) to ask what he thought my chances were at a run in February. His assessment was very positive, and he offered to nominate me. I thought it would be good to have a co-nom with a slightly different body of work, and so I messaged Lee Vilenski, who had offered me a nomination a few months earlier. Both of them were happy to jointly nominate me.

Running

I'd agreed with my nominators that Kevin would create the page late GMT on the Friday, and I'd transclude Saturday morning (GMT). I got really sick pretty much immediately after transcluding—the sickest I had been in 10 or so years. I am IMMENSELY grateful that I was asked very few questions, and had I been asked the more common 10–15, I would have seriously considered asking the bureaucrats to put the RfA on hold for a few days. The whole run went extremely smoothly, thankfully.

I am under no illusion that I had a difficult or stressful RfA. I never saw an oppose vote, I only made eight edits to the RfA page, and I was asked the fewest questions of any unopposed RfA candidate in over eight years. The run really was as mundane as it seems. I spent most of the first four days watching Conan O'Brien Needs a Friend clips and sleeping.

Reflections

Per the previous paragraph, I'm not going to give advice on how to navigate a stressful run, but I do have some tips and observations I think could be useful.

The next few points are more geared towards people thinking of running an RfA.

Recognition

My RfA was the product of the public and private kindness of many people around me. This doesn't happen without them. So, a major thank you to:

Of course, I'm also super grateful to my enforcers monitors ScottishFinnishRadish and Ganesha811, and to everyone who reached out publicly and privately with kind messages and support. It meant a lot.

Signpost
In this issue
+ Add a comment

Discuss this story

These comments are automatically transcluded from this article's talk page. To follow comments, add the page to your watchlist. If your comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache.
Thank you very much for this interesting report! More attention should be paid to such problems. --ssr (talk) 15:15, 12 April 2025 (UTC)[reply]



       

The Signpost · written by many · served by Sinepost V0.9 · 🄯 CC-BY-SA 4.0