The Signpost
Single-page Edition
WP:POST/1
27 June 2021

News and notes
Elections, Wikimania, masking and more
In the media
Boris and Joe, reliability, love, and money
Disinformation report
Croatian Wikipedia: capture and release
Recent research
Feminist critique of Wikipedia's epistemology, Black Americans vastly underrepresented among editors, Wiki Workshop report
Traffic report
So no one told you life was gonna be this way
News from the WMF
Searching for Wikipedia
Humour
Wikipedia's best articles on the world's strangest things
WikiProject report
WikiProject on open proxies interview
Forum
Is WMF fundraising abusive?
Discussion report
Reliability of WikiLeaks discussed
Obituary
SarahSV
 

Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/From the editors


2021-06-27

So no one told you life was gonna be this way

Contribute   —  
Share this
By Igordebraga, Kingsif, SSSB, Mcrsftdog, Benmite
This traffic report is adapted from the Top 25 Report, prepared with commentary by Igordebraga, Kingsif, SSSB, Benmite and Mcrsftdog.

The Signpost took a break last month, but given the weekly report on Wikipedia's most viewed didn't stop, we have two months to cover.

And the Oscar goes to... (April 25 – May 1)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (April 25 to May 1, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 93rd Academy Awards 1,571,338 The goddamned pandemic derailed the film industry, yet AMPAS still decided to award the best productions of 2020 (and early 2021). One of the major jibes before the ceremony got started was its choice of main location, a train station (pictured), and it only got worse from there. The Oscars, adamantly refusing to use Zoom (or similar) after the less than successful early awards ceremonies, was in-person only, though they added hubs in London and Paris so nominees that didn't want to (or, couldn't) go to Los Angeles could attend. It certainly felt more like the Golden Globes in a normal year with its audience at tables and such. Except they weren't drunk, nor particularly excited. The screen ban also meant there were no clips played before categories, and both the hosts and the In Memoriam seemed to be rushing to get home. So, between the average moviegoer having not seen the nominees and and a fairly uninteresting ceremony, it translated into the lowest ratings ever.
2 Mortal Kombat (2021 film) 1,563,890 24 years after the disastrous Mortal Kombat: Annihilation, the ultraviolent fighting game series returned to theaters (and HBO Max) giving everything fans hoped for, namely lots of people punching each other, good special effects, mostly accurate portrayals of their beloved characters, and dialogue featuring things such as "Fatality!", "Flawless Victory!" and "GET OVER HERE!" Hence Mortal Kombat already recouped its $55 million budget even with not as many screens available.
3 Nomadland (film) 1,449,019 One of the weirdest things in #1 was that the top category, Best Picture, was the third-to-last instead of the big prize at the end.[a] Its winner was the adaptation of a non-fiction book about a woman who decides to spend her days living in a van down by the river vandwelling. Two of the producers winning this prize also took home Best Director (#10) and Actress (#8).
4 Rohit Sardana 1,331,967 From Hollywood to India, where a local TV anchor died at just 41 from a heart attack.
5 2021 NFL Draft 1,309,263 American football got its latest college athletes, with the Jacksonville Jaguars using their #1 pick on Trevor Lawrence.
6 Shadow and Bone 1,267,141 Netflix has released a new series adapting a fantasy novel by Leigh Bardugo (pictured), following Alina Starkov (played by Jessie Mei Li) as she discovers she has the power to set her country free from the fold, a perpetually dark, barren strip of land cutting the country in two.
7 Shadow and Bone (TV series) 1,134,244
8 Frances McDormand 983,409 Best Actress at #1 came to this talented thespian for #3, a near-record third time (only behind Katherine Hepburn's four; counting the Supporting category, she now has as many Oscars as Meryl Streep!), following a pregnant policewoman from the middle of nowhere (where the director was husband Joel Coen) and an angry mother exploiting outdoor advertisement. McDormand also got a second statuette as the film's co-producer, and celebrated that win by howling! Here she's pictured with a different award she won thrice.
9 Deaths in 2021 960,124 Given the In Memoriam at #1 (speedily) used this song:
Until the dolphin flies and parrots live at sea (Always)
Until we dream of life and life becomes a dream
10 Chloé Zhao 925,572 For only the second time, Best Director went to a woman, the one responsible for #3. And Ms. Zhao's next movie will certainly show if she can do action as well as fellow winner Kathryn Bigelow, namely Marvel's Eternals.
  1. ^ Everyone would agree that the producers of the ceremony chose to close with Best Actor presuming Chadwick Boseman would win, ending the ceremony homaging the late actor. So what an anti-climax when the Oscar instead went to Anthony Hopkins, who wasn't even in attendance...

Our D-I-V-O-R-C-E becomes final today (May 2–8)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (May 2 to 8, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Bill Gates 1,371,353 The billionaire couple announced their divorce this week, after 27 years of marriage and 34 years as a couple. The divorce appears to be amicable and they have said that they will continue to work together on their foundation.
2 Melinda French Gates 1,027,961
3 Deaths in 2021 926,892
Lay me down
Let the only sound
Be the overflow...
4 Invincible (TV series) 744,955 The final episode of the first series aired on April 29. It has proved so popular that a further two series of this family-unfriendly animated superhero show were confirmed on April 30.
5 Resident Evil Village 730,516 Capcom's seminal survival horror series returned for its eight mainline title (in fact, the cover art shows there's a "VIII" hidden in "Village"), where the unlucky bastard who sought his wife in the seventh game now tries to rescue his daughter from inhuman creatures. And given the setting is Transylvania, of course there's vampires, whose leader caused quite the impact upon her reveal in a demo.
6 Cinco de Mayo 703,801 The annual celebration held on May 5, celebrating Mexico's victory over France at the Battle of Puebla in 1862.
7 Elon Musk 695,271 #1 used to be the richest man in the world, now it's this guy, who hosted Saturday Night Live. Not the first entrepreneur to have done so, but most people would rather forget the previous one.
8 2021 West Bengal Legislative Assembly election 691,857 The election in this east Indian state was held April 27–29, with the results being announced this week. All India Trinamool Congress (AITC) increased their majority. The election was marred by violence, with opposition parties claiming the violence was conducted by the AITC against them.
9 Dogecoin 679,762 Showing how fickle the cryptocurrency market is, #7 made jokes about the memetic dog-themed one he champions on SNL (on his opening monologue, Musk brought his mom on stage, who said she expected her Mother's Day gift to not be Dogecoin; and on Weekend Update, Musk appeared as a cryptocurrency expert who was questioned thrice by host Michael Che about Dogecoin) and its value fell 37%! Perhaps to compensate, right after the week covered by this report, Musk's SpaceX announced a Dogecoin-funded mission.
10 Mamata Banerjee 673,257 Despite losing her seat in the West Bengal Legislative Assembly, her party won the most seats in #8 and she remains the Chief Minister of West Bengal.

Go to war again, blood is freedom's stain (May 9–15)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (May 9 to 15, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Elon Musk 2,023,222 Billionaire Memeguy hosted Saturday Night Live on May 8. His fans thought his was the best episode ever; his detractors thought it was as unfunny as anything modern SNL puts out. Musk also managed to crash two cryptocurrencies in one week—doge- crashing after a (presumably failed) plug on SNL, and bit- crashing after Tesla announced it would no longer be accepted as payment.
2 State of Palestine 1,543,993
In this week, protests over the eviction of Palestinians from Sheikh Jarrah, East Jerusalem escalated into countless missile strikes on the Gaza Strip.
3 Israeli–Palestinian conflict 1,473,599
4 Israel 1,445,058
5 Hamas 1,206,073
6 Iron Dome 1,043,060
7 Gaza Strip 1,003,236
8 Jupiter's Legacy (TV series) 983,196
What if a superhero was morally grey? What if they, get this, killed people? That'd be crazy. Jupiter's Legacy, the first piece of media to ever explore this concept, premiered on Netflix on May 7.
9 Deaths in 2021 937,721
Well, I'll die as I stand here today
Knowing that deep in my heart
They'll fall to ruin one day
10 Radhe (2021 film) 924,247
India has sadly been going through a huge spike in cases of the pandemic, so the latest Bollywood blockbuster had to be released digitally (though foreign markets got it in theaters).

Sing, sing a song, sing out loud (May 16–22)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (May 16 to 22, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Eurovision Song Contest 2021 1,595,667 The annual (if one forgets 2020, as many would like to do; at most there was that Will Ferrell comedy, that probably brought in bigger non-European interest this year) competition took place in Rotterdam this year, in a venue that housed a COVID field hospital. As ever, Eurovision was pretty crazy, with highlights including vaporwave backgrounds, some of the most poorly executed green screening, and some guy who wouldn't put a shirt on. The winner: Italy, who sent the alt rock band Måneskin (including topless dude). The loser: the UK, who managed to get nil points. Twice.
2 Halston 1,523,384 Ewan McGregor plays Halston (1932–1990), a mononymous fashion designer and eponymous subject of a Netflix miniseries that is proof that Ryan Murphy can produce shows about literally anything (as long as they include fashion).
3 State of Palestine 1,433,840 A second week of the conflict caused the State of Palestine to be third on our list, along with several other related articles.
4 Army of the Dead 1,206,852 Before his foray into comic book adaptations, Zack Snyder started his film career remaking Dawn of the Dead. So here's him back into zombies (in fact, it's apparently based on an idea he had while working on the remake), namely a Netflix original where Dave Bautista leads a team trying to steal a Las Vegas casino's vault before the city is nuked to contain its undead infestation.
5 Israel 1,120,843 A truce closed off the most recent flare-up of the decades-long conflict after 15 days.
6 Israeli–Palestinian conflict 1,026,543
7 Hamas 992,010
8 Deaths in 2021 886,710 Breathing, is the hardest thing to do
With all I've said
And all that's dead for you
9 The Woman in the Window (2021 film) 866,684 This schlocky modern retelling of Hitchcock's Rear Window, starring Amy Adams, made its way to Netflix on May 14.
10 Mare of Easttown 824,532 HBO continues to air this show about Kate Winslet as detective Mare, who returns to Easttown Township to investigate a murder.

I'll be there for you, 'cause you're there for me too (May 23–29)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (May 23 to 29, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Army of the Dead 1,584,244 Zack Snyder's newest film, released to Netflix on May 21, stars Dave Bautista, Ella Purnell, and a digitally-superimposed Tig Notaro. The plot's about a crew breaking into a zombie-infested Las Vegas to retrieve millions of dollars before the place is nuked, but it's also about a father reconnecting with his estranged daughter—read into that what you will.
2 Eternals (film) 1,029,757 The first trailer for this MCU film—from Nomadland director Chloé Zhao—was released on Monday. If you're wondering how an Oscar winning director makes a Marvel movie, just take it from producer Kevin Feige:

We cut a little sample reel together, I remember, to show [Disney higher-ups]. And it was so beautiful, and I had to keep saying, “This is right out of a camera; there’s no VFX work to this at all!” Because it was a beautiful sunset, with perfect waves and mist coming up from the shore on this giant cliffside — really, really impressive stuff. (Variety)

3 Phil Mickelson 989,739 Mickelson won the 2021 PGA Championship on May 23; at the age of 50, he's the oldest person to ever win a men's major golf championship
4 Matthew Perry 989,188 In the years between Friends and The Reunion, Chandler starred in Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, Mr. Sunshine, Go On, The Odd Couple, 17 Again and Fallout: New Vegas. He also tried to fend off the addiction to prescription drugs that hit him while doing the show.
5 Eurovision Song Contest 2021 945,167 After the pandemic ensured the only Eurovision Song Contest in 2020 was the one with Will Ferrell, the music extravaganza featuring the best and most bombastic of Europe (and Australia) made a glorious return.
6 Deaths in 2021 894,293 I won't stay quiet, I won't stay quiet
Cause staying silent's the same as dying
7 Mare of Easttown 819,701 John Oliver joked that this series about a murder investigation is the only thing as white and depressing as the current backdrop of his show. And now there's only episode left for it.
8 Måneskin 818,137 This Italian rock band won the Eurovision Song Contest with their song "Zitti e buoni."
9 Friends: The Reunion 736,524 This special, starring the cast of the really big 90s–00s sitcom, premiered on HBO Max on Thursday. The guestlist included people who had appeared on the original series, as well as Malala, BTS, Justin Bieber, and Lady Gaga.
10 Elliot Page 716,745 Page, star of Juno and The Umbrella Academy, came out as a trans man at the end of last year. On Monday, he posted his first post-top surgery shirtless photo.

No one could ever know me, no one could ever see me (May 30 – June 5)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (May 30 to June 5, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Mare of Easttown 1,232,548 Writing/reading this Report, a pattern can be noted that articles on TV shows enter right as the season starts, and either remain steady or lose visits with more episodes, with the only thing that raises views being the season finale. This HBO drama starring Kate Winslet as a policewoman with a fractured home life investigating a murder managed to invert it, as Mare of Easttown only earned a slot by the third episode and has only grown since then, with the miniseries closer managing to the top the list – which is also a reflection of its actual ratings, with the seventh having nearly a million more viewers compared to the first!
2 Tulsa race massacre 1,178,663
On May 31 and June 1, 1921, the Black population of Tulsa, Oklahoma was devastated by attacks from a White mob. Hundreds were killed, thousands were left homeless, and the prosperous Greenwood District—known as "Black Wall Street"—was destroyed. The massacre was left out of American popular history until relatively recently; the revival probably owes a lot to HBO, as both the 2019 Watchmen miniseries and last year's Lovecraft Country both featured the events. 2020 also had the unfortunate coincidence of last year's George Floyd protests being at their height on the anniversary of the massacre.
3 Deaths in 2021 951,295 To the well-organized mind, death is but the next great adventure.
4 A Quiet Place Part II 874,861 Shh! The John Krasinski-directed horror flick A Quiet Place, about a family (led by himself and real life wife Emily Blunt) who must live their lives in silence to avoid killer aliens with amazing hearing, earned itself critical and audience acclaim as well as beaucoup bucks. It got itself a sequel, but does anyone else kind of hate it when they just slap "Part 2" in front of things? It could've been A Quieter Place, or A Quiet Place: Hold Your Breath, or A Quiet Place: Please Would You Kindly Shut The Heck Up. In any case, Jim Halpert seems to have avoided the sophomore slump with this one if online ratings are to be believed.
5 Cruella (film) 856,457 The newest Joker movie, starring Emma Stone as a campy performance artist/fashion artist/mastermind criminal that will one day skin Dalmatians, was released to theatres and Disney+ on May 28.
6 The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It 830,910 This horror movie based on the trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson was released to theatres and HBO Max on Friday.
7 Matthew Perry 742,353 Many viewers of the Friends reunion were worried about Perry after a withdrawn performance. During the show he admitted to anxiety surrounding how many laughs he would get. He has since announced that he and his fiancé had split after 4 years.
8 Naomi Osaka 709,447 Osaka was fined $15,000 for not giving a press conference after her first game in the French Open; the next day she withdrew, citing her mental health.
9 Frank Kameny 708,859 In 1957, Kameny was fired from the Army Map Service after his superiors learned of his homosexuality. He unsuccessfully fought this in the courts, and afterwards became a gay rights activist. The late Kameny, and pride month itself, was commemorated with a Google Doodle on Wednesday.
10 The Family Man (Indian TV series) 682,356 Prime Video has released this thriller starring Manoj Bajpayee as a middle-class man secretly working as an intelligence officer for India's counter-terrorist task force.

Someone to face the day with, make it through all the rest with (June 6–12)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (June 6 to 12, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 UEFA Euro 2020 1,725,754 After one year of delay, the 60th anniversary of Europe's football tournament between nations started on June 11. As of this report's cutoff, 4 games have been played. The only surprising result from these 4 is Finland beating Denmark (pictured is Joel Pohjanpalo, who scored the winning goal) However, given the circumstances (see below) the result is less surprising.
2 Christian Eriksen 1,553,804 The Danish international footballer suffered a suspected cardiac arrest in the tail end of the first half of a match against Finland, their opening match as part of #1. The match was immediately suspended while his team mates formed a protective buble around Eriksen and medics performed CPR. After approximately 15 minutes Erikson was transferred to hospital, where he is said to be stable, conscious and awaiting tests. The match resumed around 2 hours, Denmark's play was noticeably subdued, as were Finland's winning celebrations.
3 The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It 1,079,590 The third sequel to 2013's The Conjuring and the whopping eighth installment in The Conjuring Universe is based on Gerard Brittle's book The Devil in Connecticut, written about the demonic trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson (#9).
4 Ed and Lorraine Warren 995,545 Okay, so, if you ask me, the escapades recounted by these two ghostbusters (and the protagonists of the Conjuring films, in which they're portrayed by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga, respectively) have about as much truth to them as when someone drops acid and then tells you they had a conversation with Julius Caesar. But you can't say the tall tales these two have Conjured up about supernatural spirits over the years haven't made for some perfect movie material, considering just how many films the studios have been able to milk from them, including the most recent Conjuring installment (#3).
5 Logan Paul 968,238 The slightly less controversial (though not that much less controversial) half of social media's Paul brothers has lived many lives both on and off of the internet, first as one of Vine's biggest stars, then as a YouTuber, an actor, a singer, a screenwriter, and a podcaster. Now, like his brother, he's made his triumphant return to boxing two years after his first professional match, going up against none other than Floyd Mayweather Jr. (#9). I didn't watch the fight, though according to the site you're reading this on, Mayweather may have gone a little easy on him.
6 Loki (TV series) 967,253 The MCU machine just keeps on pumping. In the the first episode of this semi-retconning sci-fi crime thriller, which was released on Disney+ this week, Tom Hiddleston reprises his role as the titular God of Mischief, introduced in 2011's Thor. He gets captured by the Time Variance Authority, an organization that monitors the timelines of the Multiverse, who deem one of the versions of Loki a threat to the "Sacred Timeline", in which no multiversal war breaks out, and Loki agrees to help stop the alternate, fugitive version of himself from messing up the timeline. Confused? I certainly am!
7 The Family Man (Indian TV series) 960,776 The second season of this Indian thriller, starring Manoj Bajpayee (pictured) as a middle-class man working for the National Intelligence Agency who must balance secretly trying to protect the country from terrorists with his tumultuous family life, was released last week on Amazon Prime Video. It continues to yield positive reviews and buzz.
8 Floyd Mayweather Jr. 929,958 A boxer who had a shining professional career, being champion of four weight classes and retiring undefeated after 50 fights. Mayweather returned for an exhibition fight with #5, where him holding back led to showers of boos from the audience.
9 Trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson 895,314 Saying "a demon made me kill my landlord" is like a way more extreme version of "my dog ate my homework", but in 1981, that was the excuse given by Arne Cheyenne Johnson and his defense lawyers. You must acquit, I guess.

As told in #3, in a story that seems to have been based more on slightly convenient timing and coincidence than truth, the body of an 11-year-old boy named David Glatzel was supposedly being inhabited by a demon, so his family called in ghost hunters Ed and Lorraine Warren (#4), who then got the Church to perform an official exorcism on Glatzel. Months later, Johnson killed his landlord, apparently because the demon had relocated from Glatzel's body to Johnson's. Not only is this hilarious because it means the exorcism was a failure, but it also means that the demon waited months to actually do anything demonic.

10 Sweet Tooth (TV series) 810,631 Based on the comic book series of the same name by Jeff Lemire, this Robert Downey Jr.-produced, James Brolin-narrated Netflix fantasy series released last week takes place in a world where animal-human hybrids are being hunted down, and follows the adventures of a boy born part deer and part human named Gus as he travels across America with his human companion, Tommy, in search of Gus's mother.

Even at my worst I'm best with you, yeah! (June 13–19)

Most Popular Wikipedia Articles of the Week (June 13 to 19, 2021)
Rank Article Class Views Image Notes/about
1 Juneteenth 2,615,582 Saturday was Juneteenth, which commemorates the abolition of slavery in Texas following the Civil War. While most states have some recognition of the holiday, it took until this Thursday for President Biden to make it a federal holiday—the timing probably has a lot to do with the civil rights protest movement from last year.
2 UEFA Euro 2020 2,548,439 As of this report's cut-off, every team has played two of their three group games. Italy, Belgium and the Netherlands are already through, but will still try to win their group, for a theoretically easier round of 16 match (although the Netherlands have already won theirs) North Macedonia are already knocked out and now play for pride. However, for the other 20 teams still need to fight to stay in, with only 13 of those 20 teams making it through...
3 Cristiano Ronaldo 950,014 Ronaldo is currently playing for Portugal in the UEFA Euros. He's a pretty big deal, enough to be blamed for a stock value drop of The Coca-Cola Company after moving a bottle of Coke off the table to encourage viewers to drink water. (the true story is much more complicated)
4 Loki (TV series) 881,400 Thought WandaVision was a one time deal in "Disney+ Marvel shows that seem designed to leave the viewer confused every week"? Nope, Loki is here with its timeline variances to keep that void filled. There was even the reveal of the antagonist, known as "The Variant", an alternate Loki who not only is intent on breaking the flow of time, but is a woman!
5 Milkha Singh 872,744 Nicknamed "The Flying Sikh", a sprinter who was the last Indian man to get close to an Olympic medal in track and field with a 1956 fourth place (a woman got to the same position in 1984; the country has not had much Olympic success in running, jumping and throwing), and died of COVID-19 complications at the age of 91.
6 Christian Eriksen 866,489 Following the Danish international's cardiac arrest during his match against Finland national football team (June 12), he has been fitted with an implantable cardioverter defibrillator. Meanwhile, during Denmark's match against Belgium was paused in the 10th minute for a tribute (Eriksen wears the #10 shirt), with a banner reading "All of Denmark is with you, Christian".
7 Critical race theory 858,371 School boards around the United States are filled with talk about "critical race theory," a specific academic field that, to some critical eyes, encompasses everything from The 1619 Project to white genocide. In Washoe County, Nevada, parents even proposed equipping teachers with body cams to prevent the dastardly CRT. Liberals warn that bans on CRT—so far passed in Idaho and Florida—will have a chilling effect on discussions of racism, while conservatives boast that they would have a chilling effect on discussions of racism.
8 Deaths in 2021 830,867 When I die and they lay me to rest
Gonna go to the place that's the best
When I lay me down to die
Goin' up to the Spirit in the Sky
9 Novak Djokovic 814,589 Djkovic won the Men's Singles tournament at the French Open on June 13, taking the champion title from Stefanos Tsitsipas.
10 UEFA European Championship 691,184 Ever since 1960, the European national football teams have a tournament among them every four years. Although the goddamned pandemic ensured the latest edition (#2) had an extra year of wait.

Exclusions


2021-06-27

Boris and Joe, reliability, love, and money

Contribute   —  
Share this
By Ganesha811, 3family6, and Smallbones

Boris gives Joe an outstanding present

A diplomatic exchange of gifts involving a photo on Commons (right) was thoroughly dissected by The Washington Post, The Independent, The Times and many other newspapers.

US President Joe Biden gave UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson a $6,000 bicycle. Boris gave Joe a photograph of a mural in Edinburgh of Frederick Douglass taken from Commons. An earlier version of the story in The Times suggested that Boris' present was not really adequate. Sorry, I didn't archive the earlier story in time, but in any case The Signpost disagrees. It's wonderful that Johnson recognized the importance of US–UK shared history—including Douglass's life and general race relations in both countries. It's even better that Johnson gave a freely licensed photo available on Commons. Why waste the taxpayers' money when such a thoughtful gift is libre as well as gratis.

The photographer Melissa Highton gives due credit to the muralist Ross Blair (AKA TrenchOne). Highton is a dual US–UK national with roots in Maryland and Scotland. She says that the "incident gained a wee bit of media coverage" and that it "just goes to show that serendipitous things happen when you share openly."

More prime ministers and presidents should give such gifts. We welcome readers' suggestions in the Comments section below on what Commons photos their political leaders should give to other countries' leaders. Be sure to include the filename, e.g. for Biden to France's Emmanuel Macron, include [[:File:New Colossus manuscript Lazarus.jpg]], with a colon in front of "File".

The most reliable source on the internet?

PC Magazine interviews Amy Bruckman, Professor at Georgia Tech, and a keynote speaker at the upcoming IntelliSys 2021 Conference, who also edits Wikipedia occasionally. She states:

The content of a popular Wikipedia page is actually the most reliable form of information ever created. Think about it—a peer-reviewed journal article is reviewed by three experts ... and then is set in stone.... A popular Wikipedia page might be reviewed by thousands of people. If something changes, it is updated.... On the other hand, a less popular Wikipedia page might not be reliable at all.

Her book Should You Believe Wikipedia? will be published in 2022 by Cambridge University Press.

Canada's Global News offers a slightly different perspective but concludes with similar advice.

Arabic Wikipedia grows in size and scope

Reuters reports that Arabic Wikipedia now has more than 1 million articles. The story, written by Mahmoud Mourad, notes that in 2020 the number of registered users to the site expanded by 44%, and is now at 136,000. A brief interview with a Wikipedian, Anass Sedrati, contains this quote which gets to the heart of Wikipedia: "We can consider this as an attempt to provide knowledge to those who have not had the same opportunities as us." In another example of the Wikipedia ethos (and some commentary on our notability policies!), a second Wikipedian shares: "...We must have an article on everything that exists and on everything related to our life." Happy editing to all those over at Arabic Wikipedia!

Wikipedia, love, and marriage

They met about 2010 in a "chat room" on Wikipedia, according to The New York Times among a community of "passionate moderators, writers, and editors". In 2013 they met in person at a Wiki-wedding in New Jersey. Wikimania 2014 in London was next. The relationship heated up a bit in 2016 and again in 2019. This Pi day, March 14, the two were married celebrating with lemon meringue and apple pies. In their spare time they've managed a total of over 30,000 edits. The Signpost sends our warmest congratulations to IShadowed and Shirik.

Apparent plagiarism leads Elsevier to retract periodic table book

Chemistry World reports that academic publisher Elsevier has retracted the book The Periodic Table: Nature’s Building Blocks: An Introduction to the Naturally Occurring Elements, Their Origins and Their Uses based on accusations that the book plagiarized Wikipedia. An occasional Wikipedia editor Thomas Rauchfuss, an inorganic chemistry professor at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign was notified by another Wikipedian of the apparent plagiarism, and checked it out in some detail. After contacting the book's three co-authors without receiving a satisfactory reply, Rauchfuss notified Elsevier who pulled the book.

Canadian students write articles about Indigenous people and social justice

Canadian editorial outlet Troy Media publishes the story "Students bring Indigenous perspectives to Wikipedia", which was originally published in the University of Alberta's magazine Folio. The story reports on Dr. Nykkie Lugosi-Schimpf and one of her students, Kris Cromwell, and how they used Wikipedia in Lugosi-Schimpf's course Colonialism and the Criminal Justice System.

In the course, students created Wikipedia articles about Indigenous people and the Canadian justice system. Lugosi-Schimpf was inspired to create the course after reading a story about Erin O'Neil, the Wikipedian in Residence for University of Alberta, and O'Neil's discussion about how Wikipedia can be used for social justice projects. Lugosi-Schimpf then contacted Wiki Education to set up the course. Previously the course had students work directly with organizations and communities to fulfill the service learning portion of the course. With the COVID-19 pandemic, such in-person work was not possible and Wikipedia presented an alternative. According to Lugosi-Schimpf, it also presented a great opportunity for students as well. "Indigenous peoples have been spoken for and talked about, and I think that for students to be able to speak for themselves, about themselves, rather than have someone else tell their stories is really important." Students peer-reviewed each other's work before the final articles were posted to Wikipedia, which gave them scholarly editing skills as well as a connection to each other during a difficult time socially due to the pandemic.

Kris Cromwell relates that she was excited by the opportunity presented by the course to impact how Wikipedia depicts racialized groups. "I'm a Black woman in the Faculty of Native Studies, and I thought it was important to have something from the perspective of a racialized person with education and training in critical Indigenous studies." She created Indigenous peoples and the Canadian criminal justice system and has continued to edit. She says "while not everyone can be a journalist, everyone can be a Wikipedia editor."

An Edit-a-thon for Eternity

The Australian Christian newspaper Eternity, working with the WikiProject 1000 Women in Religion, held an edit-a-thon to increase the coverage of Australian religious women.

Two more Indigenous Taiwanese language Wikipedias

On April 15, 2021, the Atayal and Seediq language Wikipedias were launched, as reported in The News Lens and Language Magazine. Both languages are indigenous to Taiwan, and are the second and third indigenous Taiwanese language Wikipedias to be created. The launch of these Wikipedias, along with the Sakizaya Wikipedia back in 2019 (see prior Signpost coverage), are part of a language revitalization project by the Taiwanese government. Atayal is spoken by only 90,000 people, and Seediq by only 10,000, and fluent speakers of both respective languages are far fewer. In 2018, UNESCO categorized Atayal as "vulnerable" to extinction and Seediq as "severely endangered". These languages belong to the Formosan family of Austronesian languages. Most speakers are elderly.

The lab leak hypothesis on Wikipedia

Once again CNET reports on the coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic on Wikipedia. This time, the focus is on the origins of the virus: "Inside Wikipedia's endless war over the coronavirus lab leak theory." The article, written by Jackson Ryan, is clear in its descriptions of Wikipedia processes, and features quotes from involved Wikipedians. The piece was well-received on a relevant talk page, with one Wikipedian writing: "it is rare to read an article about Wikipedia that gets things broadly right".

In brief

Videos and podcasts



Do you want to contribute to "In the media" by writing a story or even just an "in brief" item? Edit next month's edition in the Newsroom or leave a tip on the suggestions page.

Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Technology report Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Essay Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Opinion


2021-06-27

Elections, Wikimania, masking and more

Contribute   —  
Share this
By Smallbones

Board of Trustees elections

2021 WMF Board elections timeline

Fourteen candidates have thrown their hats into the ring for the four vacant seats on the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees. The winning candidates will serve three-year terms. As of press time, you have one more day to submit your candidacy.

You may also submit questions for the candidates, or endorse or comment on others' questions through June 29. So far 40 questions have been submitted.

The diverse group of candidates includes four women, one current board member, and three Africans. About a dozen nationalities are represented.

The elections were cancelled last year while plans to redesign the Board were in progress. Voting will be held August 4–17 with eligible voters casting single transferable votes.

Virtual Wikimania August 13–17

Wikimania, the annual conference hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, will be a virtual event this year for the first time in its 15-year history.

Submissions for presentations are now closed, with almost 300 submissions received. Registration will open soon.

Masking IPs proposal

The WMF is starting to make its proposal to mask IP addresses more concrete. WMF Legal has stated that this type of proposal must be implemented for legal reasons, though the WMF is still gathering evidence and opinions on how best to implement it. Be sure to see the talk page for the most recent community feedback.

Another very long, and somewhat disorganized, discussion at Wikipedia:Village pump (WMF)/Archive 3#IP Masking Update seems to have significant support for simply banning IP editing if the IP masking is put into effect.

Board chair steps down, becomes WMF consultant

María Sefidari, Raystorm, has stepped down as chair of the WMF Board of Trustees. It was then announced on a Wikimedia mailing list that she would become a paid consultant. The reaction on the mailing list, starting with Chris Keating, was "flabbergasted". Michael Maggs, Philip Kopetzky and others joined in saying that it looked like a conflict of interest and a general governance mistake that the WMF would never allow WMF affiliates to get away with.

There is now also a discussion at The Village Pump (WMF), under the heading Self-Dealing on the WMF Board.

Brief notes


Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Serendipity Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Op-ed Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/In focus Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-06-27/Arbitration report


2021-06-27

Wikipedia's best articles on the world's strangest things

Contribute   —  
Share this
By Ganesha811

Wikipedia is a haven for specialized knowledge, unevenly applied. While articles on topics as important as "The Sun in culture" sit little-noticed and little-loved, we have poured time and attention into producing extremely high-quality articles on some more obscure subjects. Here are a few of Wikipedia's featured articles on the bizarre, outlandish, or simply fascinating things the world produces from time to time.

The Brown Dog affair

With a title that seems lifted from a Tintin book, the Brown Dog affair actually involves a public hue and cry in Edwardian Britain. At about 5,600 words, the full story is well worth your time to read, but in short, to quote from the lead: "it involved the infiltration by Swedish feminists of University of London medical lectures; pitched battles between medical students and the police; police protection for the statue of a dog; a libel trial at the Royal Courts of Justice; and the establishment of a Royal Commission." Nominated for FA status by the great and much missed SarahSV, this article is a reminder that the past is a massive place.

Why don't animals have wheels?

Rotating locomotion in living systems answers a question that occurs to every five-year-old shortly after they learn about cars. Why haven't animals given up their ungainly legs, paws, and wings in exchange for the ability to roll? The article, nominated for FA status by swpb, is a perfect example of how to turn inquiry into knowledge.

Cats, the coronation cut

Continuing on our mammalian theme, we come to the Chief Mouser to the Cabinet Office. This article describes a cat with a lordly salary of £100 a year, whose role is to keep 10 Downing Street, a notoriously drafty and unwelcoming home, free of vermin. It's hard to say which part of the article better exemplifies Wikipedia's appreciation of the catholic nature of knowledge – the section on partisanship with relation to the cat, or the navigation box at the bottom containing article links to all the Chief Mousers of years past. Nominated for Featured List status by Matthew.

And now for something completely different...

Anyone who has suffered through a YouTube video beset with ads will understand the frustration of American football fans who tuned in to watch the Heidi Game. Played in 1968, when TV channels were few and football was just beginning its rise to dominant popularity in the United States, the regular-season game filled up its entire 3-hour timeslot. A few minutes before the Oakland Raiders began an epic comeback, NBC decided to switch to regular programming – specifically, Heidi, a made-for-TV movie not much remembered today. Interestingly, the film's score was composed by John Williams, one year after his first Academy Award nomination. Nominated for Featured Article status by The Writer 2.0.

Honorary mention

Finally, mention must be made of Extremely Online, recently brought to Good Article status by JPxG. An enjoyable read, the article does fail to answer one key question – how much time do you have to spend on Wikipedia before you become Extremely Online? Maybe it's best if we leave that one to the philosophers.


If articles have been updated, you may need to refresh the single-page edition.



       

The Signpost · written by many · served by Sinepost V0.9 · 🄯 CC-BY-SA 4.0