Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/From the editors
Pop culture rules the top 10 this week; the list is bookended by the week's top film at the US box office X-Men: Apocalypse, while Captain America: Civil War remained in the top 10 for the fifth consecutive week. Game of Thrones gained a burst of popularity thanks to a deeply affecting final few minutes of last week's episode, "The Door", while another eternally popular manufactured conflict, professional wrestling, reappeared on the list thanks to Extreme Rules. The failing marriage of Hollywood stars Johnny Depp and Amber Heard has drawn some undeserved ogling, showing that pop culture need not confine itself to screens and stages.
For the full top-25 lists (and our archives back to January 2013), see WP:TOP25. See this section for an explanation of any exclusions. For a list of the most edited articles every week, see WP:MOSTEDITED. For the most popular articles that ORES models predict are low quality, see WP:POPULARLOWQUALITY.
As prepared by Serendipodous, for the week of May 22 to 28, 2016, the 10 most popular articles on Wikipedia, as determined from the WMF TopViews, were:
| Rank | Article | Class | Views | Image | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | X-Men: Apocalypse | 
|
1,385,606 |  |
Hopes were high for this after the rapturous critical and commercial reception given to Bryan Singer's previous X-Men film, Days of Future Past; unfortunately the reviews for the followup have been largely negative, with the film struggling to reach a 60% "Fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The $250 million it has so far earned so far worldwide is in line with Fox's expectations, but in a world where Batman v Superman can be considered a failure for not making $1 billion, this film is looking a bit pallid. |
| 2 | Game of Thrones (season 6) | 
|
964,616 |  |
The latest season of this eternally popular TV series premiered on HBO on 24 April. And after this week's shock revelation, people doubtless turned to Wikipedia to check out future titles and see if they could guess where the story was going. |
| 3 | Captain America: Civil War | 
|
796,085 |  |
Off the top for the first time this week, though it can rest easy now that it has joined the increasingly not exclusive $1 billion club. |
| 4 | Frankie Manning |
|
730,246 |  |
The pioneering dancer and co-creator of the Lindy hop got a Google Doodle on his 102nd birthday on May 26. |
| 5 | Game of Thrones |
|
693,475 | |
See #2. |
| 6 | Amber Heard |
|
679,903 |  |
Oh boy, here we go again. It was bad enough readers revelled in the public humiliation meted on her and Johnny Depp (see #7) by the people of Australia, now there is more attention directed at what appears to be a very rapid and messy marital dissolution. I could go into specifics, but I won't, because I neither know these people, nor care about their private lives. |
| 7 | Johnny Depp |
|
658,094 |  |
After a string of tabloid-fuelling relationships in the 1990s, the cult star appeared to settle down for good with French actress Vanessa Paradis, only to separate from her in 2012 after 14 years. His subsequent much shorter relationship with actress Amber Heard (see #6) has not proven as successful. |
| 8 | Deaths in 2016 | 
|
641,993 |  |
The annual list of deaths, always a fairly consistent visitor to this list, saw its average views jump after the death of David Bowie. |
| 9 | Extreme Rules (2016) |
|
561,021 |  |
WWE's latest pay-per-view pantomime took place on May 22, 2016, at the Prudential Center in Newark, New Jersey. The designated winner was Roman Reigns (pictured). |
| 10 | X-Men (film series) | 
|
561,021 | |
The ever-more convoluted film series looks safe for now, and, thanks to the rather boring but still perplexing post-credits tease, people want to know what happens next. |
The Economic Times, part of the Indian Times Group, features an interview with Jimmy Wales (also available in video format) on the topic of net neutrality and zero-rated Internet offerings (May 30).
Net neutrality has been a highly controversial issue in India for the past two years. In 2015, a pro-net neutrality Save the Internet campaign arose that vehemently criticised Indian telecom companies along with Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg's Internet.org initiative.
The campaign against Free Basics was spearheaded by lawyers, IT experts, and cultural figures like the All India Bakchod comedy collective, which made three influential YouTube videos urging people to write to the Indian Telecom Regulatory Authority (TRAI) in support of net neutrality, and to express their opposition to zero-rating schemes like Free Basics on the grounds that they mainly serve to cement existing monopolies, to the detriment of smaller and local competitors.
In February 2016, TRAI upheld the net neutrality principle and banned Free Basics and similar zero-rated services in India, a decision widely attributed to the popular campaign.
The Economic Times asked Wales for his opinion about these developments (time code 6:14 in the video), given that the Wikimedia Foundation has its own zero-rated offering, Wikipedia Zero. Wales defended Wikipedia Zero:
Our Wikipedia Zero offering follows a very strict set of principles such as no money is ever exchanged and so on. Net neutrality is such a very, very complicated topic. It's something that I am very passionate about; I think net neutrality is incredibly important. And at the same time I think that getting access to knowledge for the poorest people in the world is also very important.
Sometimes those two things can be to some degree in tension and we have to be really careful about it. I think the most fundamental thing is that it's really important that we maintain a very open and free Internet and a free flow of information. So the detailed policy options ... well, it gets very subtle ... but net neutrality is very important.
Wales has in the past commented favourably on Facebook's Internet.org project, saying in 2014 that the Wikimedia Foundation's Wikipedia Zero people were in contact with the Internet.org team and that "In my personal capacity, I am a big fan of what they are trying to do and support it fully".
In the Economic Times interview, however, Wales remained non-committal about the recent developments in India outlawing zero-rated services, saying he lacked the knowledge to give an opinion on whether the Indian government had done the right thing in clamping down on Free Basics:
I am not an expert on the specific legislation, the specific details of the Indian case. What I do say is I encourage people on all sides to come together and really think about all of the different competing values and how to best balance them. Was this the best balancing act? I'm not really in a position to say.
Wales also commented on a number of other issues in the video interview, such as the importance of getting enough good sleep, the spread of smartphones in India, the development of Wikipedias in India's regional languages and Wikimedia Foundation fundraising.
On the latter topic, Wales said that in order to fund the Wikimedia Foundation's recently started endowment, he would be approaching tech billionaires this year and ask them to "chip in" (time code 5:30 in the video). He affirmed this intent in an interview (May 30) with Austrian business magazine Trend as well, saying his main fundraising job this year is to "raise 100 million dollars".
Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Technology report Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Essay Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Opinion
The Wikimedia Foundation has published its revised annual plan for the 2016–17 financial year (July–June), which has been finalised for board approval after a month-long community consultation on Meta. Responding to a challenging fundraising environment, the organisation is cutting its planned expenses for the first time after more than a decade of unabated growth—from US$65m in 2015–16 to $63m in 2016–17. While the organisation has a track record of underspending actual expenses, the reduction of about 3% represents a shift in its planning. The change includes a slight reduction in planned headcount and adjustments to budgets such as that for grantmaking. Among identified risks, the ongoing Executive Director transition and relatively high rates of staff departure over the past months stand out as significant challenges alongside structural issues like the decline in readership, the increasingly challenging fundraising environment, and the well-being of the volunteer communities.
The centrepiece of the annual plan is "reach"—the WMF's ability to effectively reach our readers and distribute the community's free knowledge to them. This priority emerged from the strategy draft and from related community consultation in early 2016. There are a number of highlights. Field research in Nigeria and India will help WMF Tech's Reading Department to launch a new reader interface for one of the targeted regions—readership in Mexico have been studied in 2015–16. WMF Product will continue to improve the editing interface by upgrading tools such as VisualEditor (which is expected to reach mobile), and expanding the content translation tool. Community Tech will continue to work through the top 10 of the community wishlist, which includes improving diff comparison, numerical sorting in categories, cross-wiki talkpage communication, and the plagiarism detection bot; and the pageview stats tool; the creation of a central global repository for templates, and an integrated cross-wiki watchlist.
The Foundation is rolling out a new process to work with the communities in researching and building better software products. How best to integrate community voices in product decision-making has traditionally been controversial, leading to repeated stand-offs. In cooperation with Wikimedia Germany, Wikidata—which now has the third-largest community after those of the English Wikipedia and Commons—will be more deeply integrated into key aspects of all projects, such as search and infoboxes. WMF Technology is investing in better analytics and research capabilities, APIs, Tool Labs (for community developers working on tools and bots that help users maintain and use wikis), privacy protection, and site reliability.
Following the debates on how to address harassment in 2015–16, the staff aim to build online learning modules on the subject, including one on how to improve the safety of offline community meetings. The Foundation is also restructuring its grantmaking schemes and is resuming support for GLAM volunteers with a staff facilitator. The Communications Department will be enhancing the movement's reach by researching and interacting with new audiences, especially on social media, while the Advancement department (formerly Fundraising) is expanding Wikipedia Zero and new types of partnerships to foster readership. Advancement aims to raise $5m for the Foundation's newly established endowment on top of the $63m target for funding regular operations. WMF Legal will continue its input into the NSA lawsuit.
Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Serendipity
Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Op-ed
Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/In focus
For this week in the arbitration report: the Gamaliel and others case concludes. We will be covering the findings of fact and remedies.
On 4 June, the case involving Gamaliel and others (DHeyward, JzG, Arkon) concluded. In the findings of fact, seven addressed Gamaliel. These included that Gamaliel "worked on the GamerGate topic area to such an extent that he has painted many opponents with the same brush, leading to an erosion of confidence in his objectivity", his withdrawal from enforcement of the topic area, the creation of and subsequent edit-warring over a satirical Signpost news report related to Donald Trump, the creation of a userbox continuing the dispute, casting aspersions, his resignation from the arbitration committee and his edit-warring in an ANI discussion about him.
Other findings of fact included that JzG's "close of the ANI discussion indicates a standard of conduct below that expected of an administrator", that Arkon reverted Gamaliel's and JzG's attempts to close the ANI discussion he himself had started, and that DHeyward had acted in an incivil manner towards Gamaliel and made personal attacks.
The following remedies were enacted:
Along with his resignation from the arbitration committee, Gamaliel has also stepped down as editor-in-chief of the Signpost and has retired from Wikipedia.
Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2016-06-05/Humour
