Wikimedia grants less accessible for travel, equipment, meetups, and India

News and notes

Wikimedia grants less accessible for travel, equipment, meetups, and India

Contribute —

By DannyS712 and Lane Rasberry

Commons:Wiki Loves Monuments 2019 starts soon! 2018 winning images included this photograph of a fort in Badami, India.

Reform and report of Wikimedia Foundation grants process

Wiki Loves Monuments seeks proposals in August.

The Wikimedia Foundation Community Resources team, best known for operating the Wikimedia Foundation grants program, has announced major changes in the sort of projects which it will fund and also published its 2018–19 annual report. In a July email to the Wikimedia-l email list, the WMF representative announced that the rapid grant process for proposals of up to US$2,000 would no longer sponsor travel support, equipment purchases, or Wikimedia meetups. Wiki editing parties, photowalks, promotion campaigns, video campaigns, and "other" are still fundable causes. All submissions must happen between days 1–15 of a month. Lastly, the process reserves certain months only for submissions of certain campaigns, as listed:

August – Wiki Loves Monuments
September – Awareness Grants
December – Wiki Loves Africa
January – Art + Feminism
March – Wiki Loves Earth

Wiki Loves Africa seeks proposals in December.

Besides the reforms, the grants team presented the newly published Wikimedia Grants annual spending report for fiscal year 2018–19. The WMF sent US$7.4 million to 86 countries in 394 grant proposals. To meet Wikimedia community report demands the WMF also has sorted the various proposals in categories of contemporary interest, as follows: 9% went to individual applicants rather than organizations; 33% of the money went to projects in the Global South (emerging communities, less wealthy economies), and 4% went to projects which address the Wikimedia gender gap. 64% of the money went to Wikimedia affiliate organizations who received it as part of their annual plan grant overseen by the Funds Dissemination Committee or the simple annual plan grants process.

To anyone who evaluates this report, consider and speak out about what information the Wikimedia community needs to encourage good understanding of itself and planning for the future. Examples of data which would be currently hard to access include reports of funding by region (each of North America, South Asia, Europe, South America for example); evaluation of the extent to which projects delivered promised outcomes; relative impact of funding administration versus programming versus infrastructure; and counts of Wikimedia users participating in various projects. The Wikimedia platform is digitally native and produces huge amounts of metrics to interpret how grant-funded interventions change it. Anyone with ideas for what to do with such reports has the standing Wikimedia community invitation to discuss and suggest in all relevant community forums.

Derecognition of Wikimedia India

WMF director Katherine Maher attends WikiConference India 2016 presented by Wikimedia India among other equally supportive organizations

On 14 July 2019 the Pune Mirror reported news that the Affiliations Committee (AffCom) would revoke official recognition and WMF grant funding eligibility of Wikimedia India (WM India) as a Wikimedia movement affiliate. WM India members have objected to the decision and posted "Wikimedia India's Demand For A Fair And Transparent Hearing" in Wikimedia-l, as well as continued conversation in the India focused wiki mailing list. Right now, there is no particular communication process in place for derecognition of Wikimedia community groups and various social pressures prevent WM India, WMF, and AffCom from speaking openly in the wiki. These transparency challenges led one Wikimedia community member to remark being "surprised that the community has to learn about the de-recognition from the press".

While AffCom has derecognized chapters in the past and each case is somewhat different, this case is more unusual because of Wikimedia India's special place among Wikimedia affiliates. Typical Wikimedia chapters design their own programs at the community level and present them in their region. In India, the WMF has invested much more money operating programs of foreign origin within India, with the role of WM India being to represent the local community in overseeing and approving these projects. WMF programs in India include operating the first Wikimedia Foundation satellite office there from 2010–2012, piloting the Wikipedia:India Education Program there from 2012–2014, operating Wikipedia Zero in India from 2012–2016, for its television video campaign for Wikipedia awareness in Hindi language in 2017, and for its unique sponsorship relationship from 2013–present with the Centre for Internet and Society as an expert organization outside of the Wikimedia community. In these and many other collaboration attempts, culture clashes have been routine. While difficult to summarize, one commonly voiced criticism is that that WMF challenges the autonomy of the regional community by investing more money in WMF-led programs than local-community led programs. There is no organized repository of journalism, documentation, and accounting about WMF investment in India, and perhaps the narrative in the memory of the community there is not published anywhere to be found.

Google sponsored Supporting Indian Language Wikipedias Program and is sponsoring Growing Local Language Content on Wikipedia (Project Tiger 2.0)

The revocation of WM India's status recognition coincides with several other major Wikimedia projects in India. One is the Wikimedia Foundation's July 2019 India fundraising announcement in which the organization describes plans to seek donations and sponsorship in India. Another is Google's sponsorship of the Wikimedia Foundation to advance the "Supporting Indian Language Wikipedias Program". In remarks to The Signpost a WMF representative shared that the fundraising team and AffCom had taken action on relations with India independently of each other. Also, the collaboration with Google has been ongoing for some years, and the new development is a progression of years of past engagement in the region as reported in various third party media sources.

New administrators

The Signpost welcomes the English Wikipedia's newest administrators, Johnuniq, Valereee and Kosack.

← Previous "News and notes"

Next "News and notes" →

In this issue

News and notes

+ Add a comment

Discuss this story

These comments are automatically transcluded from this article's talk page. To follow comments, add the page to your watchlist. If your comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache.

Does In a July email to the Wikimedia-l email list, the WMF representative announced that the rapid grant process for proposals of up to US$2,000 would no longer sponsor travel support, equipment purchases, or Wikimedia meetups. Wiki editing parties, photowalks, promotion campaigns, video campaigns, and "other" are still fundable causes. plus email imply that funding is being concentrated on these measures with a direct impact on the projects? Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk, contributions) 16:26, 31 July 2019 (UTC)[reply]

I think I understand that WMF has derecognized WM India because of a conflict of funding. But this is really difficult to discern and I'm not sure I'm even correct. I don't mean to sound picky, but can't you simply state in a single sentence near the beginning why the derecognition has occurred in this case? -- kosboot (talk) 17:12, 31 July 2019 (UTC)[reply]
- Impossible, because there is no published resolution stating the reasons. The official explanation is that WMIN was supposed to send some documents by day X and sent them by day X+2. Comments by WMIN members mention difficulties with the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010. Nemo 13:00, 1 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

@Kosboot: I wrote the article and I agree with Nemo that the major challenge is barriers to communication. If anyone wants to either start on-wiki conversation or even better, write or interview for The Signpost, then I can give pointers to anyone who can rally to discuss and document. I am not aware of anything private or secret here, but I do see some difficult conversations without easy answers. Someone needs to be on point in these conversations to say that there is nothing embarrassing or wrong about facing a challenge and to keep the mood positive and mutually supportive. Blue Rasberry (talk) 14:12, 1 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

This was posted in the Signpost Discussion Report comments, and an editor suggested that it also be added here. Edited from that posting:

A proposal partly mentioned during the Framban discussion seems relevant to this page (and will be expanded in the next few days and linked here). It concerns full-scholarship travel and lodging endowments organized by Wikipedia editors, and hopefully legally assisted by the Foundation. These proposed Diderot Endowments, named for Denis Diderot, the founder and co-editor of the 18th century Encyclopédie, would fund at least 300 additional first-time attendees to the yearly Wikimania conference. Expanded past that, they would also endow similar full-scholarships to major continental conferences. The initial 300 could easily and quickly grow to many more. The endowment would be mainly funded by substantial donations from individuals and not corporations, would be separate from the regular fundraising efforts of the Foundation, and would be solicited by long-time Wikipedians (prominent Wikipedians such as Jimbo Wales and Katherine Maher would be asked to please assist in solicitations, as Wikipedians and not as officials of the Foundation). The Diderot scholars, initially composed of long-time editors and administrators who've never attended Wikimania, would then be able to effectively interact and strategize with their fellow editors from around the world. More on this idea shortly. Randy Kryn (talk) 12:09, 2 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Relevant: m:Wikimania/Scholarships/Vision 2015, announced in mailarchive:wikimania-l/2014-January/005417.html. The first attempt to implement it was in Wikimania 2016. Nemo 12:28, 2 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Cool. Will read it later, but good to hear that such an idea has been kicked around. Randy Kryn (talk) 13:13, 2 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks. Did a quickish but good look at the links and the longish plan, and haven't yet wrapped it into a mental map. But on first glance the plan being come up with here may be the "Way to fund it" solution to whatever emerges from an overlap of ideas. Name it an honorable name like the "Diderot Endowment" (guessing "The Diderot" will become the common name) and it could be something that could fly. Randy Kryn (talk) 16:14, 2 August 2019 (UTC)[reply]

It's your Signpost. You can help us.

Home

About